And your website audience isn't EVERYONE. As part of the web design and development services offered at MTT, inc. we try to get a handle on the marketing mission of the client we are working with. I totally understand that small business owners may not have the exact skills to clearly define their marketing objectives, audience, etc. -- that is why we need agencies like MTT, inc. However, in my client interviews, the most common answers I get regarding 'the target audience for the message' [in most cases this means a website] and who their 'ideal customer is' end up being 'The target audience is everyone and my customer is anyone'.
I often find myself responding with the phrase 'Help me help you'.
Then I offer this illustration... If you were to go stand out at the corner of Main Street and Busy Blvd. with a sign that reads 'I have something for everyone and anyone should feel free to stop and talk to me about it.'. Then I quickly ask, 'How do you think that would work out?'. Of course the response is something along the lines of 'That is ridiculous, I would never do that'. Typically, I just move on to the next question here...
'So, what would you wear?, you know... to appeal to everyone?'
'What color would your sign be?'
'What exactly would your sign say? you know... to appeal to everyone?'
'Would you move to other street corners in town, around the state, perhaps take that same show on the road around the country? -- you know... to reach anyone that wanted to hear your message?'
At this point, to be honest... some client prospects get really irritated with me. Then when i sit there and just stare at them, sometimes, it gets even worse :)
HOWERVER, there are many instances, where I don't get past the first question -- they actually start to get it and that is when the real work begins. This is not to say that this story has a happy ending. I have walked away from several initial client meetings declining to engage the client any further because not one of us can win in a situation where the audience is everyone and the client is anybody.